In 2012 we adapted our leadership structure, per ¶ 247 of The Book of Discipline of the United Methodist Church, in order to align our structure with our mission. We did this by adding Community Leadership Teams at each of our worshiping communities—Andover, Downtown, and Offerings—to assume primary responsibility for the mission in their community. In doing this we defined the roles, relationships, and responsibilities for these teams as well as previously existing teams of SPRC, Trustees, Finance, Lay Leadership, and Administrative Council.
(A) = Andover Community Member, (D) = Downtown Community Member, (O) = Offerings Community Member
Administrative Council/Charge Conference
Administrative Council brings together our largest group drawn from all of the communities for the purpose of looking at our larger vision and mission and especially how we are living into that vision and mission. Administrative Council oversees and approves the work of Community Leadership Teams, Board of Trustees, SPRC, Finance Committee, Lay Leadership, Vision Team, and the Endowment Foundation Board of Stewards. Administrative Council endorses the budget developed by Community Leadership Teams and Finance Committee, fills vacancies of lay leadership, and, as the Charge Conference, approves clergy salaries and candidates for ministry.
Marilyn Mitchell, Chairperson
Darren Wallace, Recording Secretary
Greg House, Andover Lay Leader
Amanda Brumfield, Downtown Lay Leader
Alex Gergely, Offerings Lay Leader & Lay Delegate to Annual Conference
Jennifer Gibson, Lay Delegate to Annual Conference
Sarah McGinnis, Lay Delegate to Annual Conference
Ryan Barr, Lay Delegate to Annual Conference
Mary Mowery, Community & Leadership Development
Sarah Flannery, Staff-Parish Relations Committee
Wayne Oates, Board of Trustees
Bill Pickens, Finance Committee
Jennifer Harris, Endowment Foundation
Chas Jordan, Church Historian
Mary Jo Billitter, At Large (D)
Bebe Gergely, At Large (O)
Riley Gilliam, At Large (O)
Jon Hassman, At Large (A)
Judy Minnehan, At Large (D)
Rhonda Mizeur, At Large (D)
Eddie Wray, At Large (A)
NOTE: Only the persons listed above are also the official members of the Charge Conference of First United Methodist Church
Board of Trustees
Our structure empowers local worship communities for decisions regarding use of space and empowers staff for day-to-day maintenance work and decisions. This allows the Board of Trustees to focus fully on issues of long-term property maintenance and liability. The Board of Trustees oversees, maintains, and supervises all local church property. The Trustees make decisions regarding capital expenditures, or any property issues that are safety hazards or likely to have long-term repercussions regarding the state of the building(s). The Trustees consider use of property only as relates to building maintenance, liability, and policy. They maintain adequate insurance coverage on all church property and develop appropriate risk management policies.
Class of 2026
Wayne Oates (D), Chairperson
Shannan Stamper (A)
Brenda Nally (D)
Class of 2027
Brandy Hassman (A)
Stephen Moore (O)
Scott Stewart (D)
Class of 2028
Bill Pickens (D)
John Elliott (A)
Ron Mizeur (D)
Ex-Officio Members
Marilyn Mitchell, Administrative Council Chairperson
Greg House, Andover Lay Leader
Amanda Brumfield, Downtown Lay Leader
Alex Gergely, Offerings Lay Leader
Staff Liaisons
Rev. Todd Nelson, Senior Pastor
Jennifer Gibson, Executive Director
Ryan Barr, Director of Operations
Staff-Parish Relations Committee (SPRC)
Our structure empowers the appropriate staff supervisors to provide direct oversight for most of the church’s staff. SPRC establishes and reviews employment policies; provides encouragement, support, and annual evaluations to all appointed clergy and all persons serving in top-level positions (those reporting directly to the Senior Pastor); approves ministerial candidates for certified candidacy to become United Methodist clergy; and recommends salaries and other remuneration for all clergy appointed to First UMC.
Class of 2026
Sarah Flannery (O), Chairperson
Jim Mack (D)
Class of 2027
Alexandra Kuyper (A)
Josh Weatherford (D)
Class of 2028
Scott Bryson (D)
Ruthi Sims (A)
Ex-Officio Members
Marilyn Mitchell, Administrative Council Chairperson
Greg House, Andover Lay Leader
Amanda Brumfield, Downtown Lay Leader
Alex Gergely, Offerings Lay Leader
Staff Liaisons
Rev. Todd Nelson, Senior Pastor
Rev. Brandon McGinnis, Andover Pastor
Rev. Carol Cooper, Downtown Pastor
Rev. Kayla Mattox-Frye, Offerings Pastor
Jennifer Gibson, Executive Director
Finance Committee
Our structure empowers local worship communities for decisions about how program ministry and staff money are spent. The Finance Committee establishes written financial policies to document the internal controls, makes provision for an annual independent evaluation of the financial statements by external accountants, approves an annual budget (in conjunction with the community leadership teams), approves any requests for special offerings collected during worship services, and provides financial communication to the whole church. This financial communication includes quarterly contribution statements and reports on the state of the church’s finances and budget.
Class of 2026
Bill Pickens (D), Chairperson
John Brumfield (D)
Class of 2027
Mark Kuyper (A)
Rick Lautzenhiser (A)
Jeremiah Mullins (O)
Class of 2028
George Burgess (D)
Jan Colbert (A)
Ex-Officio Members
Marilyn Mitchell, Administrative Council Chairperson
Wayne Oates, Broad of Trustees Chairperson
Greg House, Andover Lay Leader
Amanda Brumfield, Downtown Lay Leader
Alex Gergely, Offerings Lay Leader
Staff Liaisons
Rev. Todd Nelson, Senior Pastor
Jennifer Gibson, Executive Director
Ryan Barr, Director of Operations
Lay Leadership Committee
Formerly the Nominations Committee, Lay Leadership now works more broadly in managing the openings on our teams while empowering the communities to identify leadership to be a part of these shared teams. Lay Leadership has begun an evolution towards helping acknowledge and thank our leaders for their faithful service. This is no small task with over 75 people serving just in our formal leadership roles while recognizing the masses more that serve in roles beyond these official ones. Lay Leadership recommends to the Charge Conference the names of people to serve on Administrative Council, Finance Committee, SPRC, Board of Trustees, Lay Delegates to Annual Conference, and Endowment Foundation Board of Stewards, in consultation with current chairpersons and the appropriate staff members.
Class of 2026
Vicky Brown (A)
Linda Peel (D)
Class of 2027
Rebecca Merrill (O)
Betsy Pickens (D)
Class of 2028
Ashely John (O)
Kristin Weatherford (D)
Brad Rudolph (A)
Ex-Officio Members
Marilyn Mitchell, Administrative Council Chairperson
Greg House, Andover Lay Leader
Amanda Brumfield, Downtown Lay Leader
Alex Gergely, Offerings Lay Leader
Staff Liaisons
Rev. Todd Nelson, Senior Pastor
Jennifer Gibson, Executive Director
Endowment Foundation Board of Stewards
The First United Methodist Church Endowment Foundation exists to take a long-range approach to financial planning for the church. The Foundation’s Board of Stewards receives non-designated memorials, develops future givers through estate planning, and manages these funds to provide for the long-term financial health of the church. The Board of Stewards is subject to Charge Conference oversight and receives annual distribution requests from the Administrative Council.
Class of 2026
Greg House (A)
Mallory Wood (D)
Class of 2027
Will Duncan (D)
Josh Gordon (D)
Jennifer Harris (D), Chairperson
Heidi Hays (O)
Greg Monohan (A)
Class of 2028
Caroline Morton (D)
Laura Triplett (D)
Callie Owen (D)
Ex-Officio Members
Marilyn Mitchell, Administrative Council Chairperson
Wayne Oates, Board of Trustees Chairperson
Staff Liaisons
Rev. Todd Nelson, Senior Pastor
Jennifer Gibson, Executive Director
Ryan Barr, Director of Operations
Sarah McGinnis, Director of Communication & Connectional Ministries
Emeritus Steward
Howard Shellhaas
High Street Neighborhood Center Board
High Street Neighborhood Center is a joint ministry of First UMC and Calvary Baptist Church. The High Street Neighborhood Center Board is made up of members of both churches who oversee operations of the Center.
Class of 2026
Janis London (D)
Hunt Ray (O)
Class of 2027
Marie Duncan (D)
Todd McCoy (D)
Class of 2028
Betsy Pickens (D)
Pastor
Rev. Todd Nelson
Vision Team
This team is made up of the appointed clergy, the Executive Director, the lay leaders, and the chairs of all our committees. The Vision Team is the one small room where all the teams and committees intersect. The Vision Team has no authority and no budget—instead, it is a place where groups that do not meet together can find ways to support each other in our common mission and to look towards what next steps are most appropriate. Vision Team develops and recommends goals to the Administrative Council, evaluates and reports on these goals to the Administrative Council, and ensures communication and support amongst the various teams and committees.
Amanda Brumfield, Downtown Lay Leader
Rev. Carol Cooper, Downtown Pastor
Sarah Flannery, SPRC Chairperson
Alex Gergely, Offerings Lay Leader
Jennifer Gibson, Executive Director
Greg House, Andover Lay Leader
Rev. Brandon McGinnis, Andover Pastor
Sarah McGinnis, Director of Communication & Connectional Ministries
Rev. Kayla Mattox-Frye, Offerings Pastor
Marilyn Mitchell, Administrative Council Chairperson
Mary Mowery, Community & Leadership Development Chairperson
Rev. Todd Nelson, Senior Pastor
Wayne Oates, Board of Trustees Chairperson
Bill Pickens, Finance Committee Chairperson
Rev. Taylor Zimmerman, Licensed Pastoral Counselor
Community Leadership Teams
Our structure gives Community Leadership Teams several decision-making functions that are usually held by the Administrative Council, Finance Committee, Board of Trustees, or SPRC. We believe the nature of our church’s structure and identity makes this the best option. This empowers local communities to quickly make and act on decisions. It allows each of our worship communities to function in a way that best fits their context, rather than expecting each community to handle staffing, programming, properties, or stewardship identically.
Andover Leadership Team
Greg House, Lay Leader
Vicky Brown
Jan Colbert
Kathy Edwards
Marilyn Mitchell
Susan Monohan
Brad Rudolph
Ruthi Sims
Donna Thompson
Staff Liaisons
Janell Hamilton, Minister of Music
Rev. Brandon McGinnis, Andover Pastor
Darren Wallace, Worship & Congregational Care Minister
Downtown Leadership Team
Amanda Brumfield, Lay Leader
Tonya Bryson
Trey Darnell
Mike Green
Betsy Pickens
Scott Stewart
Ross Stinetorf
Staff Liaisons
Ryan Barr, Director of Operations
Rev. Carol Cooper, Downtown Pastor
Tyler Mattox-Frye, Youth & Visitation Pastor
Rev. Todd Nelson, Senior Pastor
Barry Prince, Director of Children’s Ministry
Brock Terry, Director of Music
Offerings Leadership Team
Alex Gergely, Lay Leader
Anne Copple
Heidi Hays
Wendy Katz
Abigail Mullins
Elaine Peters
Staff Liaisons
Rev. Kayla Mattox-Frye, Offerings Pastor


